Cafe Mom: Caitlyn Bradley admits she used to love watching TLC's I Didn’t Know I Was Pregnant. And, like most of us, she remained a skeptic of the oddly addicting show. ("I always used to think, how could you possibly not know that you’re pregnant?" she tells CafeMom. "No feelings at all? No symptoms?") But after being blindsided by her own surprise pregnancy, the 25-year-old mom-to-be from Buffalo, New York, sees how it's possible. And believe it or not, the only thing crazier than suddenly learning she was seven months pregnant was how she discovered the news.